What went wrong with Buffy the Vampire Slayer
I’d call the first 10 issues of the Buffy comic pretty much great, and the Wolves at the Gate and Time of your Life arcs genuinely brilliant (for reasons having relatively little to do with the Buffy-Satsu fling). For a while, this was my favourite title in comics. In the past ten or twelve issues, however, the wheels have fallen off this thing. Why? Let’s waste some time with this:
1. One-offs. After Time of your Life, the series descended into an “arc” made up of five one-off issues. That’s five too many. None of them ever felt like a complete story, and in spite of bringing in some Buffy and non-Buffy heavy-hitters as vanity writers, this was wasted issue-space.
2. Jane Espenson. Pains me to say it, given how many of the television series’ better episodes she wrote, but Espenson can’t write comics. Her one-off Harmony issue, followed by her five-part Retreat arc, demonstrate poor comic storytelling almost across the board. Key plot details occur off-panel, ideas in Retreat seem listless and un-fleshed, and Espenson’s execution-dependent dialogue suffers by having no actors to execute it. The only character who works in the whole thing is Oz - perhaps because Seth Green’s original performance was as stoic as a comic panel anyway.
3. Dollhouse. Whedon has admitted that shepherding his lame-duck series through its 2 tumultuous seasons took him away from executive-producing the comic for the last while, and it shows. Now that DH has been euthanized, things may get back on track.